Bean Leveille and James Brown are going to watch Lost, but in the very truly wrong order. Random number generator dictates which episode is watched each week. Lost is a bizarre and fascinating show that is worth re-evaluating — is it good? Is it bad?? Did it bite off more than it can chew, and is that such a crime? When removed from the mysteries, what are we left with? Let’s find out — together.

Show art by Mike Melanson.